Comments on: The Astrid Jacket on Ebay http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/ A J.Crew blog for all. Sat, 14 May 2011 05:08:11 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Leigh http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-639 Leigh Tue, 09 Sep 2008 22:57:59 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-639 Hey Francesca. I ordered this jacket in all three color and will review them when I receive them. I will also post creative outfit ideas. Hey Francesca. I ordered this jacket in all three color and will review them when I receive them. I will also post creative outfit ideas.

]]> By: Francesca http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-637 Francesca Tue, 09 Sep 2008 20:50:44 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-637 Agreed, Kara. The charcoal Astrid looks great with the heathered grey J Crew tee I bought with subtle metallic gold graphics. I also tried the watercolor Lydia blouse underneath the charcoal Astrid with my own dark grey jeans and it looked pretty good. Agreed, Kara. The charcoal Astrid looks great with the heathered grey J Crew tee I bought with subtle metallic gold graphics. I also tried the watercolor Lydia blouse underneath the charcoal Astrid with my own dark grey jeans and it looked pretty good.

]]> By: Francesca http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-623 Francesca Tue, 09 Sep 2008 12:43:51 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-623 That's great to hear, Buffy! What are you going to wear the plum color with? I think it looks fabulous with jeans, anything grey, and even a burnished olive. Tell me about how you plan on putting an outfit together around this jacket color. I always like to hear others' creative ideas. That’s great to hear, Buffy! What are you going to wear the plum color with? I think it looks fabulous with jeans, anything grey, and even a burnished olive. Tell me about how you plan on putting an outfit together around this jacket color. I always like to hear others’ creative ideas.

]]> By: Buffy http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-622 Buffy Tue, 09 Sep 2008 12:19:44 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-622 I bought this w/the 20% personal shopper in charcoal, then also in Plum. I LOVE the plum color better than the gray.and will return the gray. I think the gray COULD look more matronly than the plum colr, however that's very personal plus depends on how one wears it... really you can't go wrong with this beautiful jacket!!! I bought this w/the 20% personal shopper in charcoal, then also in Plum. I LOVE the plum color better than the gray.and will return the gray. I think the gray COULD look more matronly than the plum colr, however that’s very personal plus depends on how one wears it… really you can’t go wrong with this beautiful jacket!!!

]]> By: Kara http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-608 Kara Mon, 08 Sep 2008 17:20:24 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-608 You could try straight leg courdoroy pant either in dark or light colors and you could add a t-shirt with a subltle metallic in ivory or heather gray. You really are limitless as far as color since the jacket is a neurtal color. You could try straight leg courdoroy pant either in dark or light colors and you could add a t-shirt with a subltle metallic in ivory or heather gray. You really are limitless as far as color since the jacket is a neurtal color.

]]> By: Francesca http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-607 Francesca Mon, 08 Sep 2008 15:53:16 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-607 I picked the heather gray too. Although I love bright colors (that's why I shop JCrew) and live in the South where bright colors are acceptable year-round, I was concerned that the plum was too "of the moment" color and will look old next year. The blue is lovely, but again, too memorable when the jacket itself already is memorable on its own. So heather grey it is... though I wish I could afford to get another one in a fun color. My only concern with this is will it look too "mumsy" on a 47 yr old suburban mom (albeit with a young-looking figure)? Can you suggest ways to wear it & accessories to keep it from looking too predictable/aka too-Chanel? I plan to wear with white jeans, grey t & fierce grey booties, but any other ideas, ladies? I picked the heather gray too. Although I love bright colors (that’s why I shop JCrew) and live in the South where bright colors are acceptable year-round, I was concerned that the plum was too “of the moment” color and will look old next year. The blue is lovely, but again, too memorable when the jacket itself already is memorable on its own.

So heather grey it is… though I wish I could afford to get another one in a fun color. My only concern with this is will it look too “mumsy” on a 47 yr old suburban mom (albeit with a young-looking figure)?

Can you suggest ways to wear it & accessories to keep it from looking too predictable/aka too-Chanel? I plan to wear with white jeans, grey t & fierce grey booties, but any other ideas, ladies?

]]> By: Aasha http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-606 Aasha Mon, 08 Sep 2008 13:10:21 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-606 I was only able to try on the charcoal and it is a beautiful classic color and always a safe choice - there is more texture and shade to the fabric in person than in the photos. I liked it a lot. I also did love the blue though. I have to add, just to confuse matters, that my PS recommended the purple and she is always spot on in her taste and recommendations and I tend to regret it when I go against her advice - not that she EVER tries to persuade me. I think though that you need to be adventurous if you pick the purple though as it is sort of out there... I didn't see it in purple though. The latter is likely only going to go with jeans or maybe a grey pant. I like Leigh haven't decided which of blue or grey I would get. Sorry I am not much help. I do remember though that the "sought after" jacket of the season was the Lexington jacket with the piping in black and grey. It sold out completely and J.Crew insisted there would be NO MORE!!! Then in final sale in Dec/Jan they kept releasing lots of them. So maybe they will do the same for this jacket....? I was only able to try on the charcoal and it is a beautiful classic color and always a safe choice – there is more texture and shade to the fabric in person than in the photos. I liked it a lot. I also did love the blue though. I have to add, just to confuse matters, that my PS recommended the purple and she is always spot on in her taste and recommendations and I tend to regret it when I go against her advice – not that she EVER tries to persuade me. I think though that you need to be adventurous if you pick the purple though as it is sort of out there… I didn’t see it in purple though. The latter is likely only going to go with jeans or maybe a grey pant. I like Leigh haven’t decided which of blue or grey I would get. Sorry I am not much help. I do remember though that the “sought after” jacket of the season was the Lexington jacket with the piping in black and grey. It sold out completely and J.Crew insisted there would be NO MORE!!! Then in final sale in Dec/Jan they kept releasing lots of them. So maybe they will do the same for this jacket….?

]]> By: Allison http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-601 Allison Mon, 08 Sep 2008 00:42:16 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-601 Well there was only one color in my store (heather charcoal) and I also took the advice of my mom and personal shopper. We were all nervous about the other colors...I believe Violet from Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory came up. To each "her" own. I think I got the right color for me. Well there was only one color in my store (heather charcoal) and I also took the advice of my mom and personal shopper. We were all nervous about the other colors…I believe Violet from Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory came up. To each “her” own. I think I got the right color for me.

]]> By: Leigh http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-600 Leigh Mon, 08 Sep 2008 00:20:27 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-600 Looks like everyone here purchased a different color. How did you decide on the color? I am torn as I think all of the colors are great. The jacket is just a beautiful piece. Looks like everyone here purchased a different color. How did you decide on the color? I am torn as I think all of the colors are great. The jacket is just a beautiful piece.

]]> By: Kara http://jcrewaholics.com/behind-the-scenes/the-astrid-jacket-on-ebay/comment-page-1/#comment-599 Kara Sun, 07 Sep 2008 21:07:49 +0000 http://jcrewaholics.com/?p=1838#comment-599 I bought the blue astrid last week. I liked both the blue and charcoal but thought the blue went better with my coloring. I felt the gray was a little too subdued. I plan to wear it with jeans and a graphic tee shirt. I bought the blue astrid last week. I liked both the blue and charcoal but thought the blue went better with my coloring. I felt the gray was a little too subdued. I plan to wear it with jeans and a graphic tee shirt.

]]>